nick (c) on enclosure/boundary ness
nick carus on enclosure/boundary ness
via michel bauwens repost of nick’s reply (to a question i saw earlier and bypassed in order to rant less.. ha) [https://x.com/nick_carus/status/2122308961437151422?a=6dFqBN-e5JqmF7XJ-ow&s=20]:
An important question Chris @landrights4all, thank you.
I think that it all depends on what we mean by “enclosure” and perhaps more fundamentally, what we understand a boundary to be.
to me ness.. enclosure/boundary as any form of m\a\p
My frequesnt orientation to Alan Rayner’s work on Natural Inclusion may offer a useful perspective here.
Rather than treating boundaries as fixed lines of separation, they are recognised as dynamic, receptive and responsive interfaces – through which distinct forms remain in relationship with their surroundings.
siddiqi border law et al.. constant line law et al
Applied to the commons, this would suggest that *boundaries need not inherently exclude. Instead, they **protect, distinguish and sustain a commons while remaining permeable to the relationships, participation and flows upon which its vitality depends.
*but they do.. they perpetuate us & them ness
**to me.. this is whalespeak.. aka: safety addiction et al.. graeber violence in care law et al..
But when enclosure becomes a means of concentrating control, denying agency or severing those relationships, it risks extinguishing the very practice of commoning.
findings (aka: the things i can’t unsee) from on the ground ness deep dive and why we need tech w/o judgment
ie: the dance won’t dance unless/until it’s 1\ all of us 2\ legit free
nothing to date (ever since that day) has gotten to that root of problem
legit freedom will only happen if it’s all of us.. and in order to be all of us.. has to be sans any form of measuring, accounting, people telling other people what to do
Does this help advance your question Chris?
I’d also be very interested to hear @mbauwens’ perspective on this, particularly given the importance of boundaries, enclosure and relational governance to the regenerative potential of the commons.
michel on conditions ness et al
_____
the thing we’ve not yet tried/seen: the unconditional part of left to own devices ness
[‘in an undisturbed ecosystem ..the individual left to its own devices.. serves the whole’ –dana meadows]
there’s a legit use of tech (nonjudgmental exponential labeling) to facil the seeming chaos of a global detox leap/dance
ie: whatever for a year.. a legit sabbatical ish transition
otherwise we’ll keep perpetuating the same song.. the whac-a-mole-ing ness of sea world.. of not-us ness.. of part\ial ness.. perpetuating survival triage.. for (blank)’s sake..
_____
_____
_____
_____
_____
______


