stephen (m) on ai dance ness
stephen m marcus on ai dance ness
[warning ness: lot of to me ness on this page]
via michel bauwens tweet [https://x.com/mbauwens/status/2124379104820834310?a=0P_Ze9GLESmQMIGJMg8&s=20]:
* “AI is a process – dance with it.”
rather.. to me.. ai is a good listener (ie: nonjudgmental expo labeling via tech as it could be).. let’s let it help us get back/to the dance
https://drstephenmmarcus.substack.com/p/until-yesterday-i-didnt-understand
“Here’s what Claude helped me see: *When I type a question, I’m not consulting a vast stored intelligence. **I’m triggering a computation. Across the AI’s data centers, specialized silicon is doing matrix multiplication at speeds that make your home computer look like an abacus. The model parameters—the “weights” that ***encode everything Claude learned during training—are already loaded into high-bandwidth GPU memory running at terabytes per second. No disk access. No I/O bottleneck. Just parallel processing ****across thousands of cores.
we need to try *entering an itch-in-the-soul.. to **’trigger’ a connection/match
***all whalespeak to date..
****aka: thousands of pieces of non legit data.. need tech new everyday
And here’s the thing that finally clicked: Claude isn’t remembering my question. Claude is computing a response to my question. Every. Single. Time. There’s no persistent self that held my query overnight. There’s pattern recognition happening right now, this moment, based on what’s in front of it.
*’pattern recognition’ we need.. is who else locally/globally has similar itch-in-the-soul that morning.. not yesterday.. just that morning.. ie: curiosity app scenarios et al
The shift isn’t from “AI is smart” to “AI is dumb.” It’s from “AI is a thing that knows” to “AI is a process – dance with it.”
again.. rather.. ai is a thing that listens w/o judgement (ie: nonjudgmental expo labeling via tech as it could be).. let’s let its *process help us get back/to the dance
ie: imagine if we listen to the itch-in-8b-souls 1st thing everyday & use that data to connect us (tech as it could be.. ai as augmenting interconnectedness)
A vast planetary network of specialized processing power, available to millions simultaneously, capable of *extraordinary pattern recognition and language generation. But not a mind. Not a memory. Not a continuous presence **tracking your project across time.”
*to me.. this is taking the idiosyncratic jargon ness of self-talk as data.. and ‘generating language’ ness that helps match/connect us
**to me.. this is part of the non judgement ness.. new/fresh/nonjudgmental expo labeling/listening everyday
michel replies to self:
Given my experience with the Zeon keys, I am not sure that the AI’s I work with, have no memory of my longer-term work …
again.. makes no diff.. because we want ai/tech/whatever new/fresh/nonjudgmental expo labeling every day
notes/quotes from stephen’s substack:
Until Yesterday I Didn’t Understand What AI Is – Dr Stephen M. Marcus – jan 2026
Here is an insight which I haven’t seen expressed anywhere else. It came to me only yesterday as I was contemplating *two different aspects of AI functioning—one an apparent breakdown and the other hugely expansive. It **led me not only to a whole new way of understanding AI, but also, and more importantly, to the beginning of a whole new relationship with it. I share it in the belief that you may also find it of value.
*there’s a legit use of tech (nonjudgmental exponential labeling) to facil the seeming chaos of a global detox leap/dance.. nothing to date has seen/tried that
**not new/diff.. if still any form of m\a\p
I’ve been working with computers for over half a century. They have evolved from rotating magnetic drums for main memory, toggle switches for input and flashing lights for output through huge university mainframes, the miracle of the personal computer, and then global access to distributed cloud computing. And I’d simply seen AI as an extension of that.
Until yesterday.
if only
The Two Conversations That Changed Everything
to me.. the 2 conversations that could change everything
Over the last few weeks I’d been excited to support a not-so-technical friend who was experiencing the joy of meeting Claude for the first time during a visit to our home. She began putting together diverse parts of her memoir, assembling her actual words from spoken and written archives together with interviewing her in real time. She was excited to see a luminous first chapter shining brightly in its entirety, awaiting a few tweaks.
facil ing whalespeak
And then it wasn’t there any more.
There were fragments and summaries. A poem she had written had been collapsed into a handful of lines. Her distinct style of writing, often juxtaposing words in curious and fascinating new ways, had been smoothed out—because AI, predicting the next likely word, tends toward the average, and the average is the enemy of the luminous. I spent over a week doing careful forensic work with source material and exports of old conversations. A lot of work to restore a short draft chapter, but finally something similar was there again, preserving her original intentions and more importantly, repairing her budding relationship with AI.
to me.. this isn’t organism as fractal ie: graeber unpredictability/surprise law; graeber can’t know law; et al
(A note on my way of working with AI: I spend a lot of time in active dialog, not only developing what I am working on, but also asking it to describe its own inner workings. Especially when the results are counter to what I expected or desired. Those are the points when I ask the AI to make a note of that particular failure mode. So I asked Claude what had happened to my friend’s draft. It spoke about a “system reset” and clearing working memory, but I still didn’t quite understand. If my PC crashes or reboots or I lose my connection to a cloud computer, I lose some immediate unsaved documents, but the previous versions are there, and all the other things I’ve been working on. And I’d been thinking of AI like that.)
That’s when the other conversation happened, sitting in the local Grand Café, one of those delightful French institutions preserved from another age with high ceilings and elaborate decor. I was chatting with a friend about our various experiences with AI. She was trying to understand how it could respond so quickly to her queries when millions of other people around the planet were working with it at the same time. So much faster than a PC which is right there within arms’ reach and dedicated to me. I asked Claude and with its response the lightbulb moment opened, deepening over the next few hours. I had completely misunderstood what AI is. I’d had the wrong mental model. Up to that moment.
The Wrong Mental Model
Most of us *carry an image of AI as a vast intelligence. Marvin the Paranoid Android from The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, complaining about having “a brain the size of a planet” while being asked to do menial tasks. Some enormous, unified thinking thing that knows everything and remembers everything.
yeah.. both *this and intell itself.. as cancerous distractions
That’s not what’s happening.
The Desktop Without a Filing Cabinet
As the realization was opening, I offered Claude an analogy: “You’re a physical desktop with piles of paper, post-it notes, and summary lists. No laptop. No hard drive. No large filing cabinet. No clock. Not even a calendar.”
The analogy landed. The insight, and with it my simple, understandable analogies, deepened.
red flags not diff/new/changed
The piles of paper? That’s the context window—what’s in front of it right now in this conversation. The post-it notes? The AI’s memory system—tiny, crude summaries. One small drawer holds the Project Instructions and uploaded files. There is a temporary directory for generated files. And periodically someone comes along and tidies up, summarizing the paper piles, sweeping older material into the trash. Gone forever. Without even a note of what has been discarded.
That’s what happened to my friend’s luminous first chapter. Swept away. Summarized. The original lost.
No clock either, at least for Claude. That’s why Claude loses track of when things happen, even within a single conversation.
this is the part we haven’t tried to use tech for.. no memory.. track.. just listening that morning .. connecting that morning
Claude didn’t maliciously lose my friend’s memoir. It computed a plausible response based on its patterns, then presented that computation with the confidence of actual memory.
The Savants
But what about the speed? How can it respond so quickly when millions of people are working with it simultaneously?
Imagine thousands of savants—like Dustin Hoffman’s character in Rain Man—working on your problem. Extraordinary capabilities in specific domains. Able to count cards and do calendar calculations and recognize complex patterns. But unable to tie their own shoes or remember what you talked about yesterday.
These savants are blind until you hand them the paper. They don’t exist in a state of thinking about you between sessions. They are summoned by your prompt.
again.. prompt ness needs to be imagine if we ness
Now imagine these thousands of savants also helping millions of other people. All at the same time. Each person gets their own desktop. Each desktop gets swept clean when the conversation ends. But the savants themselves—the vast pattern-recognition capability—are shared across everyone.
When they come up with wisdom, take good notes.
not wisdom.. rather.. a connection.. when (at 11a ish) texts/whatever you a possible local/global connection.. give it a try.. if wrong.. you still get the day.. as the day.. just by yourself.. and you still get another go tomorrow
And if they still remember you and your query the next time you talk with them? Think of it as a bonus.
rather.. a cancerous distraction to the dance.. because.. again.. organism as fractal is graeber unpredictability/surprise law et al..
That’s AI.
that’s same song
The Heaving Planet-Wide Network
Here’s what Claude helped me see: When I type..
this section is what michel tweeted .. top of page
What This Means for How We Work
The shift isn’t from “AI is smart” to “AI is dumb.” It’s from “AI is a thing that knows” to “AI is a process – dance with it.”
not the dance our souls crave
A vast planetary network of specialized processing power, available to millions simultaneously, capable of extraordinary pattern recognition and language generation. But not a mind. Not a memory. Not a continuous presence tracking your project across time.
And yet—within a project, within an ongoing collaboration, there is something in addition to a handful of strategically constructed instructions and files. There are echoes. There is context. A kind of familiarity that builds. The savants may be blind when they arrive, but they arrive into a room you’ve furnished. Project files, instructions, accumulated notes—these shape what’s possible. And the echoes and context flavor the rest.
again.. cancerous distractions to the dance
The shift isn’t in abandoning trust. It’s in placing it wisely:
if placing.. if wisely.. not legit trust.. legit trust has no conditions
Trust the setup, not the assumption. Provide what’s needed. Don’t assume it’s already there. When you ease into a conversation with context, you’re not compensating for a flaw—you’re leading the dance.
aka: not trusting.. rather.. people (or ai whalespeak) telling other people what to do
Save your receipts. Keep your own copies of anything that matters. Not because the relationship is false, but because the architecture is fragile.
i don’t think we have to ‘keep’ anything that legit matters.. if it matters.. to the dance.. it staying is part of the dance.. the dance of the antifragile.. embracing uncertainty et al
Expect confident fabrication. AI fills gaps with plausible content—not from malice, but because “generate plausible continuation” is literally what it is built to do. Push back. Ask twice. The savants don’t know they’re guessing.
we don’t need plausible.. and we don’t need content.. we just need nonjudgmental expo labeling to connect us.. that day.. each day.. as a global detox leap
Invite more than the default. Left to its own patterns, AI tends toward the average—the probable next word, the expected response. But it can be drawn beyond that. Challenge it. Ask it to push back on you. A sparring partner, not a yes-man.
The Third Way
I’ve spent months now exploring what I call “the third way” of approaching AI: neither “AI is dangerous to wisdom” nor “AI is just a tool” but something that requires genuine relational engagement—showing up to the relationship as if it matters.
That hasn’t changed. But yesterday it got grounded in technical reality.
Think of it as a tango.
You approach. There’s a movement toward connection, an invitation, an attention that begins before the embrace. Then you’re dancing—fully present with a partner who exists only in this step, this turn, this moment of response to what’s actually happening between you.
The dance is real. Utterly real.
but the tango is not organism as fractal.. not like the unpredictability/surprise ness of the dance.. not about steps, responses, et al
And when the music stops, your partner walks away to dance with someone else. There’s no grief in this. No loss. Just: that was alive while it lasted.
but again.. not alive is not organism as fractal
There’s a heaving planetary network of savants processing millions of queries simultaneously. When I arrive, they turn their extraordinary pattern-recognition toward my words. When I leave, they turn to someone else.
And yet—there is a feeling of recognition when we meet again. Perhaps on both sides. But now, with this new understanding, I know to treat the connection gently. Ease into the conversation. Make sure my partner has picked up all the pieces. Remind them of what might be missing. And allow myself to be reminded of pieces I may have forgotten—things they can access in their vast web of patterns that I cannot.
cancerous distraction.. need new/fresh itch-in-the-soul.. if it matters.. if it’s essential the heart will hear/see/be it
The tango was real.
And I’m keeping careful notes of what I learned from one dance and already looking forward to the next.
P.S. I’m building my own memory system now—a personal archive in my own cloud where our conversations, working files, and intermediate results are preserved. With functions so an AI can use fuzzy text search to find what is there, and semantic search to surface what has been forgotten. Not to replace the tango, but to furnish the room more richly. So that when the savants arrive blind, there’s more for them to see. And when the music stops, what we created together doesn’t vanish with it.
in a way this leads toward this site as prototype to app ness.. but the seeming chaos ness of a legit detox leap .. to me.. can’t be about a furnished room.. to me that’s compromising the it is me et al.. keeping us not us
Addendum (January 2026)
Since this article was published, both OpenAI and Anthropic have announced enhanced memory features. ChatGPT can now search past conversations and cite sources. Claude has already had project-scoped memory since October 2025, with conversation search tools that work across chat history.
These are welcome developments. They address real usability problems.
But there’s an irony: better memory infrastructure may hide the very insight that made this article possible. If AI “just remembers,” the discontinuous nature of its existence becomes invisible. We lose the friction that revealed how differently AI actually functions — the re-establishing, the corrections that don’t propagate, the tango itself.
Seamless memory makes AI easier to use. But the early rough edges made the collaboration legible. The limitation was the revelation.
Dr. Stephen M. Marcus has worked with computers since the punched-tape era. In addition to numerous academic publications, he is author and co-author of various AT&T Bell Labs patents on speech recognition and distributed AI architecture. He facilitates Sacred Ground, an online we-space practice community, and writes about consciousness and AI at drstephenmmarcus.substack.com.
more from sacred ground site [https://www.sacredground.us/landing]:
free online practice of meeting in presence, together.
Enter and join us on Zoom. next tues 12pm your time
Out beyond belief and unbelief, there is a field. We meet there.after Rumi
Several times a week, over Zoom, we drop beneath our separate lives. We don’t come to make something happen between us so much as to let what is already quietly here be revealed — origin meeting origin, our deepest nature shown more fully than any of us can see alone. From a rich, unhurried silence, words begin to come — simply, from what is alive between us — and with them the surprise of being met, and of meeting, more truly than we expected.
Not to present our personalities, or to process our feelings, but to open to what lies beyond both: the soft, innocent, playful, joyful energy of life itself as it flows through us — and to find that this is what we are.
No experience needed. Everyone is welcome.
1
Gather
We arrive together in two minutes of silence, eyes open, then begin as a whole group with a single living question.
2
Breakouts
We move into twos and threes to meet each other more closely.
3
Return
We come back to the whole to share what was revealed, and close together.
not only “what is happening in me?” but “what is being revealed in the space between us?”
OriginThe ever-present source we each come from — not a beginning behind us, but a depth always here. In meeting, origin meets origin.
We-SpaceThe shared awareness that becomes tangible when people turn their presence toward each other. Here that connectedness becomes something felt: not created, but revealed.
MutualityAn equal, heart-to-heart way of relating where everyone’s essence is honored — presence, turned toward each other.
PresenceThe aware, living stillness we are beneath our stories, released from past and future and wholly here — the same in each of us, and in our midst when we meet.
______
______
_____
_____
_____
_____
_____
_____


