in above piece:
primary ed: fundamental human right
secondary ed: available to all
higher ed: accessible to all on basis of merit
merit: deliberately ambiguous term and means what educational officials want it to mean. when backed against the wall, they tend to define merit as tested aptitude and as we know, aptitude is what aptitude tests test.
I was a JSA claimant (@imajsaclaimant) tweeted at 4:06 PM – 15 Sep 2016 :
Michael Young, who coined the phrase ‘meritocracy’ said it is a recipe for disaster #bbcqt https://t.co/qxsA9vDGwo(http://twitter.com/imajsaclaimant/status/776542622760505344?s=17)
Fabiana Cecin (@fabianacecin) tweeted at 6:30 PM – 14 Oct 2016 :
So awesome when this happens to a term used to defend some kind of stupidity. Surprisingly often.https://t.co/l7dgwHKD50 (http://twitter.com/fabianacecin/status/787088135482138624?s=17)
A simplistic meritocratic approach to society and our education systems has failed. It’s time to stop ‘doubling-down’ on narrow education targets and results that privilege the few and, instead, embrace more holistic, open approach such as Connected Learning and microcredentialing.
As a parent with an embarrassment of almost-worthless degree certificates to my name, I owe it to my children, and those everywhere, to help build a better, non-meritocratic system. Let’s raise all the boats in the harbour, rather than focus on those that are already shiny and seaworthy.
yes that. non meritocratic system..
can’t be about displaying.. can’t be about credentialing.. begs we disengage from measuring transactions and validating people…
Jean M Russell (@NurtureGirl) tweeted at 4:10 PM on Sun, Aug 23, 2020:
Read the whole thread please.
Tldr: meritocracy is a big lie. Super BIG. LIE. A circular logic absurdity.
If you can convince people that wealth is both earned and deserved, you can save a lot on armed guards, vaults and CCTV cameras. The aristocracy once used the church to effect this legitimacy: as the English crown’s motto goes, “Dieu et mon droit” (“God and my right”). 3/
At its core, “meritocracy” is eugenics: the belief that some people are just intrinsically better than others (that’s why you often hear plutocrats boasting of their “good blood” – think of Trump here).
from david is funny:
1:03 – you don’t rise according to merit.. but instead you rise out of your ability to pretend that people rise according to merit