a raised eyebrow
A huge element to this quiet revolution, is the part that most don’t want to let go of.
It’s hard to go that far, to trust that deep, but until we do, perhaps we’re operating with yet another band-aid fix. A prettier, stronger, more humane band-aid, no doubt, but a band-aid nonetheless.
Until we completely trust in the person/learner/learning, perhaps we won’t get past our obsession with proof/consumerism/scarcity/dependence/directives.. into a world/economy that our souls (even if they can’t yet seem to believe in it, still) crave.
Project based learning is greater than…, 20% google time is so much better than…, competency based assessments are so much kinder than…, and yet.
And yes, perhaps we will get to incredible. But most likely not to breathtaking.
Incredible is good, no doubt. But is it what we would pick for our own children. Would we pass up breathtaking for our own children?
So what this means is, when we clothe each sentence with, … after they graduate or do well on some test or get that degree,.. no matter how much freedom we think we are giving, it’s not freedom.
Unless we offer 100% freedom, we offer a raised eyebrow.
This will keep most from breathtaking.
It will keep many from breathing.
Perhaps, as unassuming, and unthreatening as it seems, ..a raised eyebrow is the biggest elephant in the room. An elephant swimming.. in the compromise.
click image for image credit
When we are working together for an ideal , for the future, we shape individual according to our conception of that future; we are not concerned with human beings at all, but with our idea of what they should be. The what should be becomes far more important to us than what is , namely , the individual with his complexities. If we begin to understand the individual directly instead of looking at him through the screen of what we think he should be, then we are concerned with what is. Then we no longer want to transform the individual into something else; our only concern is to help him to understand himself, and in this there is no personal motive or gain. If we are full aware of what is we shall understand and so be free of it; but to be aware of what we are, we must stop struggling after something which we are not.
a recent example of a raised eyebrow from adult to adult – from Aaron’s little experiment:
As a style of public argument, this is highly effective, especially if salted with a pinch of condescension. It typically has the effect of shutting down debate right there because after all, who are you to question authority so?
who are you to question authority so? – has got to be nipped in the bud. it’s running schools, communities, it’s killing people/us.
No matter how many doors science could open, …
would I have closed the door on her?
Krishnamurti – The Significance of Life – free download et al
Yaacov Hecht – Democratic Education – (education cities – soccer storie – raised eyebrow – et al)
Ellen Langer – Mindfulness (focus on outcomes can make us mindless, notice the unlikely)
Mary Catherine Bateson – Peripheral Visions (swimming in the vulnerability of context)